Francis Berger
  • Blog
  • My Work

Metaphysical Confusion and Value Delusion

3/20/2019

7 Comments

 
Max Scheler (1874-1928) was a well-known and respected German philosopher during his time, but has since slipped into relative obscurity. He was a Catholic convert who later turned his back on the Church because of its rigidity and dogma. He was also a rather controversial figure and was involved in an adultery scandal that cost him a professorship among other things. Nevertheless, Scheler is a fascinating thinker. Although I do not agree with everything he expounds, much of what he argues in his book Ressentiment not only makes sense, but is, in my humble opinion, also extremely topical given the circumstances of our contemporary, resentment-fueled leftist/liberal dominated world.

In Ressentiment, Max Scheler agrees with Friedrich Nietzsche's claim that Ressentiment values result in a descent and deterioration of the individual and society away from higher-positive values to lower-negative values, but Scheler disagrees with Nietzsche regarding the source of Ressentiment. Unlike Nietzsche, who believes Ressentiment stems from slave morality embedded within Christianity, Scheler expertly argues that the actual source of Ressentiment values is bourgeois morality. Scheler essentially attests that the roots of liberalism and leftism are to be found there and not, as Nietzsche presumed, in Christianity. Nevertheless, though Ressentiment originated in bourgeois morality, Scheler admits it did gradually seep into Christianity, tainting and eventually usurping original Christian values through the centuries until it found its ultimate expression in the French Revolution in 1789.

In the following, I present a brief outline of Scheler’s views concerning the corrupting influence of Ressentiment values which, in their purest form, results in Metaphysical Confusion and, ultimately, Value Delusion. I am firmly convinced, as are many others, that our contemporary world suffers from an acute case of both. The following may help shed light on at least some aspects of our current societal malaise. Though much of the following information is not new or groundbreaking, it is my hope that exploring Scheler's ideas here might help clarify some of the confusion concerning the dominant Metaphysical Confusion of our own times.  


In order to understand Nietzsche's concept of Ressentiment properly, it must be shown in relation to the apriori hierarchy of value modalities, which Scheler regards as emotively experienced and universal, objective, and constant. From lowest to highest these modalities (with their respective positive and corresponding negative forms) are as follows: sensual values of the agreeable and the disagreeable; vital values of the noble and vulgar; mental (psychic) values of the beautiful and ugly, right and wrong and truth and falsehood; and finally spiritual values of the Holy and unholy of the Divine and idols.

Scheler argues that this apriori hierarchy of value modalities best represents Christian ethics and morality (at least in the ideal, traditional form) as it is modeled upon a belief in Divine creation and the existence of a personal, loving God. 
For individuals or societies living life within such a framework, the ethical, psychological, and spiritual issue becomes how the energy from these feeling states will be channeled so as to better benefit the individual person and society. Hence, an adulterated Christian hierarchy of ethics and values cannot, as Nietzsche argues, be the source of resentment values. Thus, it is a framework built upon what Scheler describes as Positive Value. 
Picture
On the other hand, Ressentiment represents the dark underside, or inversion, of Scheler's vision of a personal and transformational non-formal ethics of values. Scheler notes that the state of Ressentiment, as a personal disposition, begins primarily in negative psychic and emotional states; chief among these are envy, jealousy, anger, hatred, spite, malice, joy over another's misfortune, mean spirited competition, etc. Scheler also states that the sources of what he terms feeling states responses might be motivated by almost any negative experience ranging from personal criticism, ridicule, and mockery, to rejection, abandonment, and so forth.

According to Scheler, Ressentiment is highly situational in character because it always involves "mental comparisons" (value-judgments) with other people who allegedly possess no such Ressentiment feelings and who simultaneously exhibit authentic positive values. Although Ressentiment might begin with admiration and respect, it ends in a coveting of those personal qualities and goods possessed by another. In other words, what Scheler defines here is classic resentment, the kind we encounter on a daily basis in the everyday world - the kind we ourselves have felt or perhaps still feel on occasion when confronted by people who inspire feelings of inferiority or longing within us. 

Further refining Ressentiment, Scheler writes:

"Through its very origin, ressentiment is therefore chiefly confined to those who serve and are dominated at the moment, who fruitlessly resent the sting of authority. When it occurs elsewhere, it is either due to psychological contagion—and the spiritual venom of ressentiment is extremely contagious – or to the violent suppression of an impulse which subsequently revolts by "embittering" and "poisoning" the personality." 

A person mind-poisoned by resentment would have flows in the direction of unethical action, away from the positive and toward negative and lower values on the apriori hierarchy of value modalities. No longer respecting any sense of Divine Creation and unable to view the world through the lens of Christian love, the resentful shift their values in direct opposition to the original value modalities. This is initially a reverse horizontal movement from positive to negative that leads to a descending movement from higher to lower.
Picture
For Christians, these movement from the positive to the negative and from the higher to the lower at the individual level epitomize sin and transgression. They represent shifts away from the Divine - movements away from the knowledge of being made in God's image through love. The recognition of these shifts from the positive to the negative requires repentance in order to be absolved, but through repentance, Christianity does offer the mechanisms through which such psychic and spiritual transgressions can indeed be absolved. According to Scheler, once a Christian has repented a shift inspired by Ressentiment, he or she has the opportunity to once again realign with Positive Value and continue pursuing the proper flow of spiritual, psychological, and physical energy.

But what of individuals who refuse or reject repentance or disregard the very concept of being made in God's image through love as embodied within the hierarchy depicted above?

Scheler classifies the inability or refusal to align oneself with the apriori hierarchy of values as Pathological Ressentiment. At the individual level, Pathological Ressentiment leads to a deadening or numbing of common sympathetic feeling states and the higher psychic or spiritual feeling states. Put another way, individuals plagued by Pathological Ressentiment not only have disordered emotions and emotional states, but are essentially cut off from the higher, ascendant spiritual states. Since they reject the very concept of being made in God's image and the love of a personal God, the Ressentiment-imbued essentially cast themselves into a state of Metaphysical Confusion eventually leading to what Scheler calls Value Delusion. The ethical, psychological, and spiritual issue of how the energy from these feeling states will be channeled so as to better benefit the individual person and society are perverted and take on an inverse form.

Metaphysical Confusion at the level of the individual is bad enough on its own, but if Pathological Ressentiment infects a large number of individuals in a given community or society, it can have profound societal repercussions as well.

​Metaphysical Confusion at the societal/cultural level results first in a complete inversion of the apriori hierarchy of values, which is then complemented by the vertical assent of this inverted hierarchy. What once occupied the top of the hierarchy is now perverted and placed squarely at the bottom; hence, the vertical no longer represents an assent from the lower to the higher, but rather the vertical assent away from a misunderstood higher toward a falsely exalted lower.
Picture
In the inverted Metaphysical Confusion hierarchy, Divine Creation and Divine Love are placed firmly at the bottom of the stack and are afforded the smallest amount of territory possible. In fact, the values of the Holy and unholy are completely stripped of any reference to the authentic Divine and are instead presented as nothing more than hypocrisy and superstition.

As bad as that is, what makes the predominant flow in the hierarchy of Metaphysical Confusion even worse is the perversion and elevation of the other lower levels of the hierarchy. This, in essence, is the crux of Value Delusion - that is, a flow away from the misrepresented Divine up into the "higher" values. Thus, the mental values level, which was once one rank below the top, is now one rank above the bottom. In addition, rather than being the domain of truth and falsehood, beauty and ugliness, and so forth, the level of mental values becomes the home of political ideology and nothing more. Furthermore the vital values, which focused on nobility and vulgarity are replaced by the negative values of fear and security. The values of utility occupy the summit of the inverted hierarchy of Metaphysical Confusion where they serve as the new idols of worship within the Value Delusion world.  

Moreover, unlike the apriori hierarchy, the inverted hierarchy offers no corresponding positive values towards which an individual could shift, thereby making any sort of shifting virtually impossible. Seen in this light, the hierarchy of Metaphysical Confusion and Value Delusion offers no freedom within its structure. It is a totalitarian system par excellence. There is only one possible way the flow can go and no absolution is offered to any who refuses to follow the one possible direction the structure offers within its framework. 

The Metaphysical Confusion / Value Delusion hierarchy diagram above well illustrates current circumstances in the contemporary West. The hierarchy can be applied to nearly all leftist/liberal societies in the modern West and historical leftist/liberal societies such as those found in revolutionary France and Bolshevik Russia. 

The contemporary West is utterly steeped in Value Delusion, so much so that the vast majority of its people can no longer envision any other form of ascent than the one presented by the hierarchy of Value Delusion. A cursory glance at most media sources in any Western country is enough to confirm this. Of course, this state of Value Delusion is hardly surprising considering the Establishment's intentional and skillful instilling and harnessing of Ressentiment over the past two centuries or more. There should be no confusion about this whatsoever. Whatever benefit the Enlightenment offered has been thoroughly sabotaged by the Establishment's utilization of resentment as a means of consciousness distraction and manipulation.  

Value Delusion represents but a portion of what modern people are up against. What can or should be done in the face of this world of Metaphysical Confusion and Value Delusion will, for the time being, remain the subject of future posts. In the meantime, I believe Scheler's concepts of Metaphysical Confusion and Value Delusion offer clear insights into the nature and the scope of the many challenges modern people face, namely spiritual alienation and a disordered metaphysical conception of Reality at the level of consciousness.

Note added: The diagrams and some of the information included in this post were extracted from the following source. 
7 Comments
palintropos
3/22/2019 03:04:58

Scheler is new to me, and with Nietzsche I've only read Birth of Tragedy. If I'm reading correctly the divine order is reversed (because of utilitarian values?) leading to resentment and the darker emotions as driving forces. Certainly can't argue with that. Whereas Nietzsche thought of Christianity as an order of slavery and inherently wrong. Or am I missing something?

Reply
Francis Berger
3/22/2019 10:17:17

Scheler argues the slave morality Nietzsche criticizes penetrated into and eventually replaced Christian love and morality from the 13th century onward; hence, true Christian values and love were not the source of resentment as Nietzsche claims.

I see the logic in this. Scheler uses feudal society to exemplify the lack of resentment in traditional Christian society (everyone knew their place, no one protested to move up the hierarchy, etc.) It's a bit simplistic, but I get what Scheler means.

According to Scheler, this all changed when resentment seeped into the system. Suddenly, peasants weren't happy being peasants anymore and the merchant classes all strove to become lords. This is resentment-fueled "love."

Here's the thing though. We can't go back to feudal society - so how can Positive Value (non-resentment based love) be re-established without going back to the past?

Our current system is based on value delusion (the reversal of divine order), which stems from resentment. This helps explain why utilitarianism and pathological altruism are considered the highest values. In the divine order, your duty was to love God, yourself, your family, and your neighbors. The value delusion world regards this sort of love as selfish and too simple.

Your job today is to love Mankind far more than yourself, your family, your nation, etc. It's an impersonal kind of love based on the abstract rather than the concrete. This kind of thinking is what drives our current politics and society.

Reply
palintropos
3/22/2019 14:30:41

Thanks for your response. That makes sense to me.

I lived in India for a few years. People were happier there than in the US, no question about it. I certainly thought it was because of the caste system. The pressure was off, so to speak. Although there were strivers working in the IT sector and they reminded me of Americans.

The rich Indians weren't happy with us foreigners though because we tended to treat our servants better which made them look bad. LOL.

Americans were gung-ho on ending the caste system but I had my doubts. In that country of many, many sub-ethnicities and even languages, I thought caste was the only thing holding it together. They had zero civic virtue. They would do just about anything if they could get away with it. Bribery was/is everywhere. Bakshish.

I would think that the West had a quality of civic virtue that held us together. But, can you have civic virtue without whites? Or is it Christianity? American blacks are Christians but they have very poor attitudes towards civic virtue. Where does civic virtue come from?

Reply
Francis Berger
3/22/2019 17:08:44

For better or for worse, the Enlightenment had to happen. It brought Christians out of childhood. The problem seems to this - Christians and other modern people haven't evolved since then in terms of consciousness. We can't go back to feudal times - that would be reversion - a return to childhood. We need to move forward into adulthood, but we can't do that if we are stuck in post-Enlightenment consciousness.

The modern world is stuck in this post-Enlightenment level of consciousness and it is doing a great deal of harm.

I address the civic virtue question in the comment below.

palintropos
3/22/2019 15:06:11

The more I think about civic virtue and it's uniqueness to Europeans the more I wonder if it isn't genetic. Say, thousands of years ago there was a population bottleneck where those surviving Europeans passed on a gene which causes an individual to sacrifice his ego for the common good.

For instance, the concept of waiting in line. There are no laws about this. Europeans just do it naturally. Whereas in just about every other part of the world the idea is totally alien and cannot work without constant brutal enforcement. Maybe the Chinese might wait in lines? Can't remember if I've ever seen them do that though.

Reply
Francis Berger
3/22/2019 17:03:12

The Japanese among others have a strong sense of civic virtue. The Japanese, for example, are famous for cleaning up after themselves in sports stadiums. Most Europeans would never consider doing anything like that, so I am fairly sure it is about more than just genetics.

Reply
palintropos
3/22/2019 23:53:54

You're right. Japan is the exception. But it proves the rule, methinks. Sports stadiums I'm not familiar with. Certainly there is corruption and bad behavior in European/white dominated countries but compared to the rest is limited. Well, I've never been to Russia. I hear it's pretty bad there. But, that may be due to communist suppression of Christianity.


Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Blog and Comments

    Blog posts tend to be spontaneous, unpolished, first draft entries ranging from the insightful and periodically profound to the poorly-argued and occasionally disparaging.
     

    Comments are moderated. Anonymous comments are never published (please use your name or a pseudonym). 

    Emails welcome:

    f er en c ber g er (at) h otm   ail (dot) co m
    Blogs/Sites I Read
    Bruce Charlton's Notions
    Meeting the Masters
    From The Narrow Desert
    Synlogos ✞ Aggregator
    New World Island  
    New World Island YouTube
    ​Steeple Tea
    Berdyaev.com
    Adam Piggott
    Fourth Gospel Blog
    The Orthosphere
    Junior Ganymede

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    April 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012

    Picture
    A free PDF is also available in My Work. 
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.