Francis Berger
  • Blog
  • My Work

The Wrong Turn And Its Ending

5/3/2020

6 Comments

 
The wrong turn the West took about two or three centuries ago is a subject I have addressed many times on this blog. By wrong turn I am referring specifically to the West's gradual and, eventually, sudden abandonment of the Divine in favor of materialism. It's difficult to pinpoint exactly where and when this wrong turn took place. In fact, it would be more accurate to think of the larger wrong turn as a series of smaller wrong turns spread over the course of many political, social, religious, and economic events beginning some time after the collapse of the feudal system and the waning of the Catholic Church's authority in the West.

Traditionalist-minded Christians are keenly aware of the spiritual/historical wrong turn the West took sometime during the Renaissance, and they quite correctly lament the de-spiritualization brought about by the abandonment of medieval hierarchy and authority. In light of this it is little wonder so many traditionalists hunger for a return to some kind of localized feudal structure held together and inspired by the unifying and stabilizing power of a strong church. And who can blame them? After all, despite its many flaws, faults, and shortcomings, medieval Europe was an inherently Christian society; that is, Christianity permeated everything and formed the foundation of all aspects of European civilization and culture, to the point that the term Christendom was not only accurate, but also made complete sense at every level of analysis. It is the loss of Christendom traditionalists lament most; and what many desire, above all else, is a return to a time of Christendom - the realignment of civilization and God. Achieve this, many traditional Christians argue, and re-spiritualization will be assured. 

Though I am inclined to sympathize with visions of a revived Christendom, I believe traditional Christians who long for a return to such an arrangement are missing the bigger picture when it comes to the wrong turn and the cascading negative consequences it has unleashed. Christendom was thoroughly Christian, but this thoroughness had its limits and, to a certain extent, had already served its purpose by the time the first Renaissance blossoms flecked the medieval landscape.

Traditional Christians correctly identify the wrong turn, but the limits of the traditional Christian mindset become evident in how it defines the wrong turn. Feudal medieval Christendom was a civilization built upon the promise of salvation from sin through obedience to an external authority. For traditionalists, the wrong turn culminated in the rejection of external religious authority as the guarantor of salvation from sin. According to them, all modern sins can be traced back to that point when Western people turned away from the church, which was the guarantor of God's will and the implementer of God's plan for creation on Earth. By the same token, the sins of the modern world would be vanquished the very instant modern Western people repented their egregious material sins and willingly embraced external religious authority once again. Put simply, the only way forward would be a return to the past - to a rigid social structure stressing and enforcing the primacy of spiritual with the aim of mass salvation from sin. 


Once again, I sympathize with this outlook to a certain extent. Given the choice between our modern, perverted world and Christendom, I would likely choose Christendom, but this choice immediately raises a very pertinent question: Where would that put us spiritually? Well, if my estimations are correct, it would put us right back at the point before we took the wrong turn, which means we would be facing the same dilemma our ancestors faced when they gradually but ultimately willingly chose materialism over the Divine - when they actively began turning away from the deeper promise of everlasting life in favor of the shallower promise of never-lasting life. 

The problem of Christendom is a problem of freedom and authority. Traditionalists tend to idealize the stability and congruity of the past without considering the obvious limitations the past enforced on human freedom. Christendom's Christianity was mostly an enforced top-down arrangement in which being a Christian was largely a matter of default. Rigid social structures, the lack of social mobility, and limited material means to which most people had access created a civilization in which personal salvation was largely a matter of knowing your place and obeying the rules.

In this sense, Christendom was a phase of spiritual childhood, but it was a spiritual childhood marred by incessant physical and material limitations that made life difficult, grueling, and short for the vast majority of the population. As far as I can tell, Christendom offered no concept of spiritual maturity or development in this world. At the risk of sounding flippant I would argue Christendom's spiritual mission was to ensure all Christians remained good little boys and girls in this world in order to make it to the next world after physical death. Thus, as far as Christendom was concerned, spiritual adulthood was not a matter for this world, but the next. As a result, any return to Christendom would likely entail a step back into that spiritual childlike state - a veritable Never-Neverland populated by Peter Pans and other eternal kids whose sole purpose in life would amount to little more than making sure they did not end up on Santa Claus's naughty list before Christmas Day. 

Concepts like spiritual childhood are largely a matter of consciousness. The Renaissance and the other subsequent movements away from Christendom reveal a shift of consciousness in the West. People were no longer content to be spiritual children. They began to sense they could do more in this world and that their lives in this world required more from them in return. This shift in consciousness is what traditionalists identify as the wrong turn, but I would argue that the wrong turn is not to be found in the consciousness shift itself, but in the choices made after the consciousness shift occurred. 

The collapse of feudalism and fading of church authority marked the beginning of our spiritual adolescence. Like physical adolescence, our spiritual adolescence was marked by increasing personal autonomy, the desire to improve one's material situation, the inclination to explore the world, the eagerness to test newfound abilities, and the inspiration to reinterpret the meaning and purpose of life, both mortal and eternal. Part of this shift in consciousness entailed improving material conditions for the majority people in this world. The campaign to make the world more comfortable and livable was present throughout history, but the shift of consciousness out of spiritual childhood into spiritual adolescence provided the momentum needed to secure the complete alteration of human life. This alteration included the Industrial Revolution and all the political, social, and economic transformations that stemmed from it. Our spiritual adolescence vastly improved standards of living; Western people generally became richer and freer.

These developments suggest that the purpose of spiritual adolescence is mostly preparatory. Like physical adolescence, spiritual adolescence is an in-between phase during which the foundation for adulthood is meant to be created. In physical adolescence this includes biological strengthening and ripening (which is mostly innate and unconscious) and active preparation through education or the acquisition of certain skills that will allow for certain degrees of autonomy and success in the world. Our spiritual adolescence also contained a great deal of mostly innate and unconscious strengthening and ripening, but we have come up gravely short in terms of education and skills preparation. Material progress is perpetually condemned as the chief cause of Western Man's spiritual malaise, but I would say the fault lies not in the progress itself, but in our attitude toward the progress. That, in essence, is where the wrong turn happened. 

When I look upon the massive improvement in the material living standards that occurred in the West with the advent of the Industrial Revolution, I see a force that wanted to improve physical conditions in an effort to improve spiritual conditions. I see a force that wanted to free people from material challenges, hardships, and suffering in the hope that the time and energy liberated from these developments could be invested into the higher spiritual purpose of attaining spiritual adulthood in this world. Simply put, I see a force that aspired to alleviate the pressing concerns of physical survival in order to deliver the time and focus needed to deepen our sense of spiritual survival. I see a force whose original aim was not to drive Western Man away from God, but a force that provided the material means through which Western man could move closer to God. In other words, the freeing from material concerns over the last two centuries should have led to an increased freeing for spiritually. What we have managed to achieve instead is a freeing from material concerns followed almost immediately by an imprisoning by materialism. We managed to build the ship we needed to get to our desired destination, but instead of sailing to that destination, we have decided, collectively at least, to imprison ourselves on the ship and set off on a seemingly never-ending, pointless, and destination-less pleasure cruise.

Our spiritual adolescence should have been a time of harnessing the material for the further development of the spiritual. Instead we have fallen captive to the material and have abandoned all notions of the spiritual. In this sense, we are now in a worse position than those who lived in the spiritual childhood of Christendom. Despite traditionalist arguments to the contrary, we cannot return to spiritual childhood anymore than we can return to physical childhood. Any attempt to do so would result in an absurd farce (imagine grown men and women wanting to do nothing more than recite nursery rhymes and play in sandboxes all day long). By the same token, we have lost the map that would have guided us to spiritual adulthood. As a result, we are stuck in the teenage wasteland of materialism with nowhere left to go but down. 

Individually there may be hope for some, but at this stage our collective wrong turn appears irrecoverable. This phase of spiritual adolescence will not lead to spiritual adulthood at the collective level, nor will it continue on into perpetuity. This phase of collective spiritual adolescence, the wrong turn we have collectively taken will simply end.

And that will be that. 

Note added: Dr. Bruce Charlton's recent post concerning the karma of materialism (Rudolf Steiner's phrase) offers some lucid insights into our current predicament. I highly recommend it.

Note added: The ending of spiritual childhood or traditional Christendom should have heralded an era that laid the groundwork for the advent of another form of Christendom founded on an era of spiritual adulthood. In this sense, Christendom should have evolved from its traditional conception into something more aligned with the shift of consciousness from childhood to adolescence to adulthood. Instead, we chose to abandon the concept of Christendom altogether in favor of materialism in the spiritual adolescent phase. This makes the kind of realignment required to reimplement Christendom in the West all but impossible at this point. Materialism, which is antithetical to God, is now probably irreversible and will likely play out  until it reaches its inevitable end in some form of partial or total collapse.  

6 Comments
bruce charlton
5/4/2020 08:44:28

@Frank - That strikes me as an accurate account of the history of our current condition.

I agree that the condition seems to be, and very likely is, irreversible. And yet, the condition is always reversible in an individual if he can be honest with himself - which is a much more difficult thing than generally supposed.

For a (Romantic) Christian this is based on the very simple faith that God is the Creator and our loving parent - *therefore* everything necessary is always possible to everybody - using resources that are available to each and all specific individuals.

Anyone who is and continues to be honest with himself about himself will - I think - escape any mental trap and will discover all the necessary truths.

Reply
Francis Berger
5/4/2020 10:22:53

Great comment, Bruce. You are right; a great deal is possible at the individual level, but the collective level is another matter entirely. Perhaps the day will come when alignment can come at the collective level as well, but for now I feel this exclusively the realm of individuals and, at best, small, tightly-knit groups like families, or a small circle of believers.

Reply
Jake
5/4/2020 23:20:22

I like this essay, despite my skepticism. My skepticism comes from the possible fact that most of the men involved in undermining traditional Christendom did not seem to have in mind some kind of positive "spiritual adolescence leading to adulthood," but rather detested Christianity altogether.

But that's not quite true: Descartes and Newton were believers in God. Bacon - not so much. And the Philosophes were a nightmare of anti-Christian thinking, leading to Comte and positivism, Jeremy Bentham's awful utilitarianism, etc.

So I think the idea is provocative and insightful, but I'm not sure how much truth there is in it. Did God intend for the end of feudalism and traditional society to lead to this spiritual evolution? Did some or any of the men who were involved it it? Who or what was the primary cause of this desires spiritual growth that ended in catastrophe?

Reply
Francis Berger
5/5/2020 06:27:13

You've made a valid point, Jake. I believe men who detested Christianity or wished to undermine it existed even when the Church had total authority and Christianity was the only game in town. Thus, when the Church began to lose its authority, these sorts of men/movements were finally able to step boldly onto the stage, as it were.

Addressing developments from a collective perspective has obvious limitations as there are always specific exceptions to the general movement. Regardless, think of spiritual adolescence as our own "material" adolescence; that is, chiefly as a time of challenging, rebelling, discovering, testing, and ideally learning. Adolescents begin challenging the authority of their parents, rebel against most authority in general, try to discover new experiences and modes of being, test their limits and capabilities, and, if they have any sense learn from the positive and negative consequences of their choices in order to make the "good" choices that will lead them successfully into adulthood.

Anti-Christian thinkers like the Philosophes, Comte, Bentham, and all the rest of them were a part of this challenging, rebelling, and discovery phase, but their tenets ultimately should have been rejected, the same way a teenager who ploughs into a sex, drugs and rock-and-roll lifestyle or some other prolonged harmful way of hedonistic/material living should eventually learn from and reject said mode of living.

But materialist thinking was embraced rather than rejected. Challenging the Church's static authority was a positive step. If we did not do that, we would remain nothing more than children; very much like kids who never grow up, never leave home, and never develop their own authority. There was no evolutionary thrust left in feudal Christendom. It had run its course.

Positivism, reductionism, etc. were all rebellious challenges to the former mode of being and they should have been nothing more than part of the learning process. We should have recognized and turned away from the obvious limits of these modes of being. This would have helped set us back on the proper path, renewed and reinvigorated. Of course, we still may not have known what the proper way forward would have been, but we should have known what the improper way forward definitely was!

But we didn't do that. Instead we embraced materialism the same way a wayward teenager embraces drug culture or gang life or living in the basement doing nothing but playing video games embraces these as proper and desirable modes of being.

Yes, I believe God did intend the end of feudalism and traditional society as a path toward spiritual evolution. God is a loving parent. Like any loving parent, He wants his children to grow up to be adults; and He wants to have fruitful relationships with these adult children. He wants his children to understand that they are like Him; that they contain the seed of his power; that they too can become play a role in creation. No parent in this world wants to keep their children locked into eternal childhood where the child does nothing more than worship and obey the parent (and any parent who does want that is psychotic).

But here's the thing. Adolescents ultimately make their own choices. A parent can raise his child well. Despite a good upbringing, the teenager might ultimately choose a destructive and harmful life (and there is not much a parent can do about that in the end). The same holds true for our relationships with God. We have freedom/free will. When it comes to our decisions, God has no real power over us. We are free to choose whatever it is we choose. If we choose properly, we remain aligned with God and spiritual evolution continues. If we make the wrong choice, we become mis-aligned and will suffer the consequences.

And that's where we are now, collectively speaking - a veritable teenage wasteland where we have collectively made the wrong choice and have stuck to it - for well over two centuries! Of course, right choices are still available at the individual level (see Bruce's comment above), but collectively? Well, it will take a lot to rediscover the proper path.

Reply
Sean Fowler link
5/4/2020 23:36:37

Their stomachs are full and they have forgotten me. Might hunger and material deprivation be the foul tasting medicine that would do the most good.

Reply
Francis Berger
5/5/2020 06:30:14

@ Sean - Suffering might inspire some to see the light, but I imagine others will simply continue looking to material means to alleviate their suffering. If the suffering is acute enough, they will willingly surrender everything to end the suffering. That appears to be what the Establishment is aiming at (at one level).

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Blog and Comments

    Blog posts tend to be spontaneous, unpolished, first draft entries ranging from the insightful and periodically profound to the poorly-argued and occasionally disparaging.
     

    Comments are moderated. Anonymous comments are never published (please use your name or a pseudonym). 

    Emails welcome:

    f er en c ber g er (at) h otm   ail (dot) co m
    Blogs/Sites I Read
    Bruce Charlton's Notions
    Meeting the Masters
    From The Narrow Desert
    Synlogos ✞ Aggregator
    New World Island  
    New World Island YouTube
    ​Steeple Tea
    Berdyaev.com
    Adam Piggott
    Fourth Gospel Blog
    The Orthosphere
    Junior Ganymede

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    April 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012

    Picture
    A free PDF is also available in My Work. 
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.