Francis Berger
  • Blog
  • My Work

Will Misotheism Become The Supreme Moral Imperative Of Our Times?

7/1/2020

15 Comments

 
When did atheism first become a moral imperative? The Enlightenment? The French Revolution? Some time in the nineteenth century? The moment Nietzsche declared the death of God? The First or Second World War? The Sexual Revolution?

It is extremely difficult to pinpoint the exact time unbelief in the existence of God became a strongly-felt principle that compelled our civilization to act in ways it had never previously acted before. Nevertheless, somewhere in the above-mentioned span of history lies a tipping point - a point at which all the small, accumulated changes accrued over the centuries initiated a significant change in the world. Somewhere within that stretch of time, rejecting the existence of God went from being considered an acceptable thing to do to being considered the right thing to do. 

The moral imperative driving atheism has held up rather effectively. Unbelief in the existence of God is now viewed as a sign of sophistication, reason, and intelligence. Atheism is the mark of self-respecting individuals who understand 'scientific' reality and refuse to let their lives be cowed by superstitious fairy tales and obsolete medieval morality. 

Nevertheless, early self-professed atheists understood that their right to un-believe in the existence of the Divine was intrinsically connected to the rights of others to continue believing. Though most atheists considered theists to be misguided, superstitious, and foolish, they tended to respect the right of believers to be believers. But as is the case with most issues that boil down to rights, this ideal state of mutual respect became untenable. As the moral imperative driving atheism continued to expand and strengthen, it gradually drove believer norms, practices, and symbols out of the public domain. Thus religious unbelief, which began as a private, individual right, soon became a public moral imperative, while religious belief, more specifically in the West, Christianity, was systematically relegated to the margins of the public sphere.

The moral imperative driving atheism began to fade the moment unbelief in the existence of God became dominant. Once atheism (Godless leftism) became the dominant belief system in the West, it ceased being a moral imperative and became more of a prerequisite. Within this framework, belief in the existence God was still technically permitted, but only if it was subordinated to the ruling temporal system of unbelief represented by idols such as science, reason, humanity, democracy, equality, liberalism, and all the rest of it. As a result, belief in God has become a moot point. Though the issue of belief versus unbelief in the existence of the Divine technically remains open to debate, the debate itself has been declared unimportant and devoid of any practical value.   

When this occurred, atheism began to shift toward the moral imperative of antitheism. To truly do the right thing and live in the right way, atheists had to do far more than harbor unbelief; they had to adopt the view that belief in God was not only silly and misguided, but positively wrong and harmful. Thus, antitheism - recently promulgated and made famous in the public sphere by Dawkins, Hitchens, et. al - has replaced atheism as the new moral imperative.

In this time and place, unbelief in God is no longer sufficient. Being on the right side of civilization and history now demands belief in the existence of God be vociferously attacked, criticized, and ridiculed in the public sphere. Furthermore, the moral imperative of antitheism also demands religion and belief in God be ruthlessly singled out and blamed as the root cause for nearly all of humanity's maladies and suffering. This milieu makes it morally unacceptable for atheists to remain purely atheists; being accepted as politically and, more significantly, morally correct requires far more than mere unbelief; it also entails treating all belief in the existence of God as positively stupid, offensive, and, at its core, evil. 


The moral imperative of antitheism continues to drive our current time and place, but in my estimation we are coming to the tail end of this period. Though atheism and antitheism have both proven extremely effective in turning people away from God, I get the sense both of these moral imperatives have essentially served their respective purposes in the spiritual war. Atheism has lured people into consciously and willingly rejecting the very idea of the existence of God and the existence of the Truth that God radiates, while antitheism has succeeded in relentlessly attacking and undermining those who continue to maintain their belief and faith in the Divine and Divine Truth.

Don't get me wrong, not believing in the existence of God and denigrating anyone who believes in the existence of God are still 'the right things to do' in the here and now and will continue on unabated, but I get the sense that this poisonous fusion of atheism/antitheism will soon be augmented by a new overarching moral imperative, one specifically crafted for the times we are currently experiencing. This new moral imperative will appear in the form of active and open misotheism - that is, in the form of explicit expressed hatred of God.

Here's the thing - atheism and antitheism both stem from the principle of unbelief. The atheist and antitheist rejection of God and Truth is based on the relativist, positivist, and reductionist  conviction that God and Truth do not and cannot exist in reality. However, the metaphysical rejection of the existence of God also includes the metaphysical rejection of the existence of supernatural evil. Put another way, for most modern people, the active and willing atheist and antitheist rejection of God also denotes a refusal to believe in the existence of the devil. For the atheist/antitheist, neither God nor Satan are real.

For the demonic forces waging war against God, Truth, and Creation, this arrangement represents a compromise. It has been argued that the greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world he doesn't exist, and the devil has certainly succeeded in doing that. The demonic forces understand that tempting people away from belief in God also necessitates the relinquishing of belief in Satan. This unbelief in both God and Satan alleviates the explicitness of rejecting Good in favor of Evil, but it has come at the price of compromise. I suspect this time of compromise will soon come to an end.


Unlike their victims and minions, demons cannot harbor unbelief in God for the simple reason that they know God exists - they know God is real. They know God is real because they know they themselves are real. In light of this, they understand that God and Creation are Good, and that Satan and Destruction are evil. They know the value of Truth, Beauty, and Virtue. They are painfully aware of the beauty and truth of Creation and the promise of eternal life in Heaven beyond this world, but they reject it - all of it - and work feverishly to tempt every individual human soul to do the same.

As stated earlier, inspiring unbelief in the existence of God has served the demonic forces well, but it has come at the price of inspiring unbelief in the existence of Satan. Under this arrangement, demonic forces have successfully manipulated people into believing that turning away from God does not implicitly or explicitly involve turning toward the devil, but instead involves a turning toward a 'real' higher good (humanism, equality, democracy, hedonism, whatever) that exists firmly within perceived material reality.

This paradigm is quickly coming to an end. The devil no longer desire to convince the world of his nonexistence. On the contrary, he wants to emphatically assert the reality of his existence, but he understands that any true validation of his existence can only occur through the full acknowledgement of the existence and reality of God. Consequently, we have reached a stage in which the demonic forces feel confident enough to push humanity from the unbelief path to damnation and steer it firmly onto the path of fully conscious and aware self-damnation. Demonic forces are working to make the reality of their existence obvious to everyone, but this endeavor automatically includes raising human awareness about the  existence of God as well. Like God, the devil now seems to want people to become fully aware of the metaphysical reality of Good and Evil; to ensure everyone knows that he and God are real. 

The inversions and manipulations the demonic forces have utilized over the centuries to turn people away from God are becoming increasingly blatant and transparent. The perceived gray area in which many have erroneously sheltered is diminishing and will soon disappear. The reality of Good and Evil is becoming evermore obvious and undeniable, even to those who refuse to believe in such realities. Satan is currently asserting the reality of his existence. The Prince of Lies wants every soul in the world to accept the reality of his truth and make it a new moral imperative going forward. And what is the reality of Satan's truth?

Misotheism - a voracious and limitless hatred of God.

Declared, open, and explicit hatred of the Divine - a hatred based on firm belief rather than on unbelief in the existence of God - will become the moral imperative of these times. The demonic forces are confident that the vast majority of humans will reject the Divine even after the reality of God's existence is made explicitly clear. More than that, the devil seems convinced most humans will actively choose to join his endless and terrible hatred of God, and by doing so, become fully and consciously committed to destruction and their own self-damnation via a choice made from a position of belief rather than from a position of unbelief.

I harbor hope and faith in an opposite outcome for many individuals. In the meantime, I suspect the moral imperative of misotheism will become increasingly detectable and prevalent in the coming weeks and months. 
15 Comments
Serhei
7/2/2020 16:57:33

I was gifted a volume of Science Fiction short stories by one Ted Chiang rather representative of Silicon Valley mindset but with an evident interest in religious themes. The metaphysics were routinely unpleasant (apart from one Tower of Babel story which was merely materialist — the builders find that God does not need to protect Heaven from their tower because their universe is made to wrap around so that digging into the sky leads you to come out the bottom of the Earth). Particularly speaking to modern incipient misotheism was “Hell is the Absence of God” where the God’s existence is quite open, his Heaven is a bodiless Boring Heaven, and he beats people over the head with arbitrary a-moral miracles to induce devotion (angels appear periodically and cripple some people while arbitrarily healing others). In the author’s note, Chiang says that he was inspired by reading the book of Job and says that it seemed to him more consistent that, having seen Job reconcile himself to God’s authority to do as He pleases, God should kill Job rather than restore his prosperity. So Chiang wrote a story where God does exactly that. Bleah!

However, such a misotheism is weak because it relies on constructing a God to suit one’s hatred from the most unpleasant features of human religions. I expect the misotheism that next comes down the pipe to have slightly different features.

Reply
Francis Berger
7/2/2020 17:48:37

@ Serhei - Those stories sound . . . well . . . exactly what I would expect from a Silicon Valley mindset with an interest in religion.

I agree with your final statement. Wholeheartedly.

Reply
William James Tychonievich link
7/2/2020 19:06:16

It’s very hard to imagine belief in the existence of God becoming widespread again any time soon. Nor do I think the increasingly obvious existence of evil makes theism any more believable for most people. After all, the existence of evil has always been considered one of the main lines of evidence *against* the existence of God.

I agree that Hitchens-style antitheism is becoming passé, but I don’t think misotheism is the next step. What makes someone like Richard Dawkins seem quaint is not that he doesn’t believe God exists, but that he takes the whole God thing seriously enough to argue so earnestly against it. People nowadays take the complete irrelevance of God so much for granted that the crusading atheist is beginning to seem as much of an eccentric as, say, a crusading disbeliever in flying saucers.

Reply
Francis Berger
7/2/2020 21:15:03

@ Wm - Good points. I am inclined to agree with the skepticism about the belief in God becoming widespread in the near future. As you say, for all intents and purposes, God has become irrelevant for most people. But it was this irrelevance that got me thinking along this line.

If God is irrelevant, than so is Satan - that is, if God does not exist, neither does the devil. I got to wondering about how the devil might deal with being rendered irrelevant - to being relegated to same plane of non-existence as God. Of course, his perceived non-existence plays to his advantage, but I began to wonder if he might have overplayed his hand; that he might actually now crave to have people comprehend and accept the reality of his being.

If people became acutely aware of his existence, they would also become acutely aware of the existence of God. My thinking was that Satan might use this awareness to convert unbelief in God into outright hatred of God. It's all speculation on my part, but a rise in misotheism among unbelievers (and perhaps a few believers as well) would not surprise me one bit.

Reply
Serhei
7/3/2020 00:28:25

> the existence of evil has always been considered one of the main lines of evidence *against* the existence of God.

In contrast to the 'natural' evil typically referenced in such arguments, an experience of purposive evil of sufficient malice makes one question how *anything* good could exist unless there was some counterbalancing force for good. In that sense it acts as an argument for the existence of God.

For myself that experience came when listening to a talk by David Brin (yet another misotheistic science fiction author with Silicon Valley mindset) about 'how to talk to religious people'. I can't find that exact talk right now, but his apologia for Sauron is easy enough to find on salon.com.

Reply
Jwb
7/2/2020 21:46:40

From my reading of scripture, the antichrist at some point claims to be god and requires all to worship him as god. antichrist being both "against" Christ as well as "in place of" Christ. Utilizing a role reversal function: i am the true god, this Jehovah god is the evil one. To pull this off, it does seem prudent to increase his visibility and diminish the unbelief in the supernatural.

Reply
Francis Berger
7/3/2020 18:17:35

@Jwb - Good point.

Reply
Andrew
7/3/2020 16:06:41

I can easily imagine the anti-Christ saying he's the real-good because he's for total equality, murdering babies in the womb, etc., while Christ is bad because of reality.

Reply
Francis Berger
7/3/2020 18:18:59

@ Andrew - Great comment. Those reasons are why many people reject Christ now (no anti-Christ required)..

Reply
Donald
7/3/2020 18:42:59

I think your choice of the word misotheist is inspired here (as opposed to, say, satanist).
Although hating God implies His existence, and Satan’s, that is a rational realization, not an emotional one. Hitchens, Dawkins, et al still valued rationality (too much so perhaps!) and had to reject both. Your essay resonates with me because what I see today is actual hatred of beauty and truth, if not yet explicitly God. What a demonically wonderful baby step! Once you hate truth and beauty (and God), you want to not only destroy them but be delivered from them! And the path is built for the Antichrist.

Reply
Francis Berger
7/3/2020 20:34:28

@ Donald - Thanks for the excellent comment. It really helped clarify something for me regarding this post. People might not hate God explicitly, but they certainly harbor an explicit hatred for Truth, Beauty, and Virtue, which are often described as the philosophical concepts of God.

The constant and prolonged assault on these concepts are indeed nothing more than a veiled assault upon God; an open and declared hatred of Divine Creation.

Reply
Michelle
7/3/2020 20:28:12

Your posts hits home for me. I am relatively new to Catholicism (even though I went through 18 years of schools that said they were Catholic- maybe that was my problem) and I am still learning and understanding my faith. I am a modern woman raised by modern parents living in a modern society with modern friends. I came back to the Faith when I opened my heart and mind in a search for truth and used logic and reason to get here. So here I am but still struggling with the "superstitious fairy tale" stuff, and very much up until recently in the belief in the devil. It wasn't until the birdemic started that I realized, without any doubts, that this global response, seeping in evil deeds and intentions, to a mostly benign virus had to be orchestrated by an evil larger than man alone. I am still learning.

Reply
Francis Berger
7/4/2020 00:27:01

@ Michelle - Thanks for the comment. It's interesting that you mention learning. I just finished writing a post about that.

Concerning the struggle to accept the supernatural, it is worth remembering that materialists reject the supernatural yet expect rational adults to accept that a man becomes a woman through the simple act of verbal declaration - a veritable miracle that is then fully supported by the state and its legal apparatus. Thinking about examples like that usually helps me get over any wavering metaphysical doubts.

Reply
William Wildblood
7/4/2020 16:57:46

Excellent post, Francis. I think you are right. We have moved from the destruction phase to one of outright inversion. After all, Satan always wanted to be God, not a god but God. His whole downfall was caused by jealousy and resentment and he plays on these qualities in human beings. Apparently, psychopaths like to present themselves as victims. It's the same process at work.

God allows this to test the human heart, to bring out what's really in it. A sound heart will reject the inversion but a rotten heart will stand revealed.

Reply
Francis Berger
7/4/2020 22:33:17

Thanks, Wiliam. That's a good point about jealousy and resentment. We certainly are seeing a great deal of that manifesting now.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Blog and Comments

    Blog posts tend to be spontaneous, unpolished, first draft entries ranging from the insightful and periodically profound to the poorly-argued and occasionally disparaging.
     

    Comments are moderated. Anonymous comments are never published (please use your name or a pseudonym). 

    Emails welcome:

    f er en c ber g er (at) h otm   ail (dot) co m
    Blogs/Sites I Read
    Bruce Charlton's Notions
    Meeting the Masters
    From The Narrow Desert
    Synlogos ✞ Aggregator
    New World Island  
    New World Island YouTube
    ​Steeple Tea
    Berdyaev.com
    Adam Piggott
    Fourth Gospel Blog
    The Orthosphere
    Junior Ganymede

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    April 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012

    Picture
    A free PDF is also available in My Work. 
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.